How to be a Great Mentor

Want to know how to be a great mentor? In a world where 76% of people think mentors are important, yet only 37% have one, your willingness to step into this role is more valuable than ever. The good news is that it doesn’t take perfection—just intention, empathy, and a few practical skills.

Why Great Mentors Make a Difference

Great mentors create real, tangible impact. They accelerate growth, build confidence, and help their mentees navigate the complexities of their career with greater clarity. But many new mentors wonder: Where do I start? What does “great” actually look like in practice?

At PushFar, we’ve seen that the best mentors aren’t always the most senior or experienced—they’re the most engaged, reflective, and open. Whether you’re mentoring formally through a structured program or informally helping a colleague, these ten simple, research-backed tips can help you make a lasting difference.

1. Listen More Than You Talk

One of the most common misconceptions about being a great mentor is that you need to be a fountain of constant advice. In reality, the most impactful mentors know how to hold space and listen actively. By listening more than you talk, you create an environment of psychological safety where your mentee feels truly heard and respected. This builds a foundation of trust that is essential for an effective mentoring relationship.

To put this into practice, focus on asking powerful, open-ended questions that encourage reflection. Instead of jumping to solutions, try prompts like, "What does success in this area look like to you?" or "What's the biggest obstacle you're currently facing?" This shifts the focus from your experience to theirs, empowering them to find their own answers. Remember, your role is to be a guide, not a guru.

2. Help Set Clear Goals

Mentoring sessions can sometimes become pleasant but aimless conversations if they aren't anchored to a specific purpose. A great mentor acts as a clarifying force, helping their mentee translate vague aspirations like "getting better at networking" or "improving leadership skills" into a tangible roadmap for success. This focus is what turns intention into meaningful progress and prevents the mentoring relationship from losing momentum over time.

A powerful and widely used tool for this is the SMART goals framework: ensuring goals are Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. Learn more about The Importance of Goal Setting in Mentoring. Manually tracking these goals can be cumbersome. This is where a dedicated platform becomes invaluable. On PushFar, you and your mentee can set and define shared goals directly within the platform, add milestones, and track progress over time, ensuring accountability and a clear, visible path forward.

3. Share, Don’t Solve

It can be tempting for experienced professionals to immediately jump in and provide a direct solution to a mentee's problem. However, this can inadvertently create a dynamic of dependency and undermine the mentee's own problem-solving skills. The goal of mentoring is not to provide a fish, but to teach the mentee how to fish for themselves.

Great mentors understand that their role is to empower, not to instruct. Instead of offering a direct command like "You should do X," try sharing a relevant personal story. Frame your experience as one possible path, not the only one. You can use phrases like, "In a similar situation, I tried Y, and the outcome was Z," or "One thing that failed spectacularly for me was A, and this is what I learned from it."

Sharing your failures is often more valuable than sharing your successes, as it normalizes struggle and encourages the mentee to develop their own critical thinking.

4. Be Consistent and Reliable

Trust is the currency of any successful mentoring relationship. While sharing profound insights is valuable, the foundation of that trust is built on something much simpler: reliability. When you consistently show up on time, follow through on your commitments, and give the mentee your undivided attention during meetings, you send a powerful, implicit message: "You are a priority to me, and you are worthy of my respect."

This consistency creates a safe and predictable space, which is essential for allowing the mentee to be more vulnerable and open. This doesn't require grand gestures. It's about the small, professional habits: responding to messages in a timely manner, being prepared for your meetings, and never cancelling at the last minute unless absolutely necessary. Each fulfilled promise, no matter how small, adds another layer to the foundation of trust.

The PushFar platform helps to automate scheduling and sends out reminders to both mentor and mentee, making it far easier to maintain a reliable mentoring cadence.

5. Create a Safe, Inclusive Space

For a mentee to truly grow, they must feel safe enough to be vulnerable. This means being able to share their uncertainties, admit to mistakes, and ask "silly" questions without any fear of judgment or negative consequences. This concept is known as psychological safety, and it is the bedrock of a successful mentoring relationship.

Fostering this safety is an active process. It involves practicing empathy, maintaining confidentiality, and being mindful of your own biases. Small affirmations like, "That's a great question," or "Thank you for being so open about that," can make a huge difference. To learn more, read about What is Psychological Safety and How to Build It. PushFar supports this by providing a framework for professional relationships and offering resources that help mentors develop these crucial 'soft skills.'

6. Offer Constructive Feedback

Giving honest feedback is one of the most valuable—and most challenging—roles a mentor plays. Constructive feedback is the catalyst for real growth. However, if delivered poorly, it can damage confidence. The goal is to be a supportive mirror, reflecting reality in a way that empowers the mentee to change.

A proven method is the SBI (Situation-Behaviour-Impact) model. Instead of vague criticism ("Your presentation was confusing"), you provide specific, observable examples: (Situation) "In the team meeting this morning," (Behaviour) "when you presented the quarterly data, you moved through the slides very quickly," (Impact) "and I noticed some people in the audience looked a bit lost." This is factual, non-judgmental, and focuses on the impact of the behaviour, not the person.

7. Stay Curious

Great mentoring is not a one-way street. It is a dynamic, reciprocal relationship. When you, as a mentor, show a genuine interest in your mentee's world, their experiences, and their unique perspective, you build a powerful, human connection.

Acknowledging that your mentee has expertise and knowledge that you don't possess is a powerful way to level the playing field and foster a true partnership. The PushFar ecosystem is built on this power of curiosity, with matching technology that encourages cross-departmental and cross-industry connections, creating countless opportunities for mentoring to become a genuine, two-way street.

8. Celebrate Wins

A relentless focus on "what's next" can be exhausting. Celebrating wins is a neurologically vital part of the process. Acknowledging progress boosts motivation, reinforces positive habits, and builds the mentee's confidence.

Make a conscious effort to ask about recent successes, no matter how small. Did they successfully handle a difficult conversation? Did they finally understand a complex spreadsheet? Acknowledging these moments explicitly can be more impactful than an hour of strategic advice.

PushFar’s goal-setting and note-tracking tools create a living record of the mentoring journey, providing tangible evidence of their 'wins' and creating a powerful visual map of their growth.

9. Respect Boundaries

A mentoring relationship is fundamentally a professional development relationship, not a personal friendship or a therapy session. Clear boundaries are about creating safety and clarity. Establish expectations at the very beginning regarding the frequency of meetings, communication between sessions, and the scope of topics.

Crucially, a great mentor knows their limits. If a mentee is experiencing significant personal distress, your role is not to be their therapist, but to gently guide them towards professional resources, like HR or an Employee Assistance Program (EAP).

10. Reflect and Improve

The most effective mentors, even those with decades of experience, approach each relationship with a 'growth mindset,' recognizing that there is always more to learn. Make reflection a regular part of your process.

After a session, take five minutes to consider what went well and what you might do differently next time. Don't be afraid to solicit feedback directly from your mentee. PushFar supports this by providing mentors access to a rich library of ongoing learning resources, including expert-led blogs, detailed guides, and live webinars on best practices.

Final Thoughts

The journey to becoming a great mentor is not about achieving perfection. It is not about having all the answers.

As we've explored, it is about being present, intentional, empathetic, and consistently open to growth – both for your mentee and for yourself. It is about listening more than you speak, sharing experiences rather than dictating solutions, and celebrating the small wins along the way. By embracing these principles, you can create a profound and lasting impact.

Want to grow your impact as a mentor?
Book a demo to see how PushFar supports you.