How to Structure a Productive Mentoring Meeting in a Structured Mentoring Program
The Before, During and After of a Productive and Successful Mentoring Meeting

A Mentoring Meeting Overview
Within any mentoring relationship, the primary purpose is to help the mentee progress and grow, both personally and professionally. A mentoring meeting or session is when a mentor and mentee come together to share expertise, exchange knowledge, and solve problems.
Whilst a mentoring meeting is generally driven by the mentee, both parties should have a clear view of what to expect from each session and the relationship overall. Every relationship is different—some meet weekly, others monthly—but without a transparent structure it’s easy to drift into broad discussion. The purpose of mentoring is progress; a structured mentoring programme gives both parties a way to follow up on actions and keep conversations focused on agreed objectives.
Below is what should happen before, during, and after your mentoring meeting.
Before the Meeting
For a mentoring relationship to be productive, mentor and mentee need a shared understanding of what they want to achieve and clear expectations.
- Prepare in advance: review each other’s professional background to understand skills, expertise and context.
- For a first session, the mentee should email the mentor with a CV and a short background summary.
- The mentee should reflect on goals, current challenges, and priority topics; draft an agenda and share it with the mentor for input.
During the Mentoring Meeting
1) Start with a brief informal catch‑up
Mentoring is about human connection as well as outcomes. Begin with a short personal check‑in to build rapport and trust—this makes honest conversations easier.
2) Review the previous session (if applicable)
Revisit any actions agreed last time. The mentor provides constructive feedback and both parties discuss progress. For example, if a learning course was set as a goal, the mentor should ask the mentee to reflect on what they learned and how they applied it.
3) Confirm the focus for this session
Arrive with a proposed topic (from the pre‑shared agenda), but refine it after the progress review. Agree the most relevant focus for today.
4) Plan solutions and next steps
Explore options to overcome challenges and outline a practical plan the mentee can execute. Clear planning makes the meeting more valuable and actionable.
5) Set actions and schedule the next meeting
Close by documenting an action list for the mentee (and any mentor actions). Ensure both parties agree on what success looks like and confirm the date/time of the next session.
After the Meeting
Follow up promptly
The mentee should send a follow‑up within 24 hours, thanking the mentor, capturing key learnings, and restating the agreed actions.
Provide constructive feedback
The mentee should share what was most helpful so the mentor can refine their approach. Mutual feedback strengthens the relationship.
Stay committed to actions
Following through on commitments is essential; missed actions can discourage mentors and slow progress.
Respect healthy boundaries
The mentee should respect the mentor’s boundaries. Contact outside meetings is fine when appropriate, but mentors may have limited time. Mentors, in turn, should respond to reasonable questions, reflect on feedback, and share any useful links or resources discussed.
Final Thoughts
Mentoring relationships benefit both parties, but they succeed when there is mutual respect, clear expectations and honest communication. A structured mentoring programme ensures meetings remain focused, actionable and genuinely impactful. This helps the mentee get the most from the relationship, overcome challenges, and achieve personal and professional goals.
If you’re looking to build a structured mentoring programme, visit PushFar—the world’s leading mentoring and career progression platform—and sign up for free.
Join Now Free Running your own mentoring programs?
Request a Demo
Explore more articles...
Similar mentoring, career progression and learning articles and resources by PushFar, you might like to read.
Mentoring for Mental Health in the Workplace

For many of us, work is a major part of our lives and a place we spend the majority of our time. It's our source of income and a place to connect with some of our favourite people. Everyone should feel happy in their jobs. It's vital that as an employer you prioritise the physical and mental health of your employees.
Read More →
Why Great Mentors Embrace the Roles of Teacher and Learner

This article explores how mentors who stay open to learning from their mentees can experience personal and professional growth in unexpected ways.
Read More →
The Powerful Benefits of Mentoring For Both Employees and Organisations
